Sourdough baking has been making a delightful comeback in recent years, thanks to its unique flavours and the sense of satisfaction that comes from creating your own bread from scratch. At the heart of any great sourdough bread is a well-maintained sourdough starter. However, even the most seasoned bakers can encounter issues with their starters. One of the most common questions is: can your sourdough starter go bad?
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive deep into the world of sourdough starters. We’ll explore what a sourdough starter is, the signs that it might be going bad, and how to revive it if it’s salvageable.
So, let’s roll up our sleeves, put on our baker’s hats, and learn how to ensure our sourdough starters stay healthy and happy!
What Is a Sourdough Starter?
Before we get into the nitty-gritty of determining if your sourdough starter has gone bad, let’s first understand what a sourdough starter is and why it’s so crucial in sourdough baking.
A sourdough starter is a mixture of flour and water that captures wild yeast and bacteria from the environment. These microorganisms naturally occur in the flour, and when mixed with water, they create a thriving ecosystem that ferments and leavens your bread.
Over time, as you feed and maintain your starter, it becomes a flavourful and active culture that imparts the characteristic tangy taste and airy texture to sourdough bread.
Signs Your Sourdough Starter Might Be Bad
Now that we’ve established the importance of a healthy sourdough starter, let’s explore some telltale signs that your starter might be on the decline or, worse still, gone bad.
1. Offensive Odour
One of the most obvious signs that something is amiss with your sourdough starter is a foul or unpleasant odour.
But if this is your first time making a starter, how do you know if it smells right?
Unfortunately, I can’t embed a smell into this blog post so I will try to describe a normal sourdough starter odour and also what bad smells to sniff out!
Normal sourdough starter smells:
- Sour and Tangy – A healthy sourdough starter typically has a sour and tangy smell. This is the result of the lactic acid produced during fermentation and is completely normal.
- Yeasty – Sourdough starters can also have a yeasty aroma, which is akin to freshly baked bread or beer. This smell is a sign that the wild yeast is active and contributing to the fermentation process.
- Fruity or Nutty Notes – Depending on the flour you use and the composition of your starter, you might detect subtle fruity or nutty undertones. These nuances are considered normal and can add complexity to the aroma.
However, if you detect any strong, putrid, or rancid smells, it is a clear indicator that something has gone wrong.
- Rancid or Putrid Smell – If your starter has a rancid, putrid, or even rotten odour, then it is likely to have spoiled or have been contaminated. This could be due to the growth of harmful bacteria or mould. In this case, it is best to discard the starter and start fresh.
- Acetone or Nail Polish Remover Smell – A strong, nail polish remover-like odour could indicate that the starter has undergone excessive fermentation and produced an excess of acetic acid. This can make the starter overly sour and less pleasant to work with.
- Ammonia-Like Smell – An ammonia-like odour might develop if the starter has been left unfed for an extended period. It indicates that the yeast and good bacteria in the starter have exhausted their food supply. To remedy this, feed your starter to rejuvenate it.
- Sulphur or Rotten Egg Smell – A sulphurous, rotten egg smell could be a sign of the presence of unwanted bacteria or overripe fermentation. This is not normal and may require discarding the starter and starting a new one.
- Mouldy or Musty Odour – If your starter smells mouldy or musty, it could be due to mould contamination. Mould growth can be harmful, so it is best to discard the starter.
As you can see (or smell!), a sourdough starter should have a sour, tangy, and yeasty aroma, with subtle undertones depending on the type of flour used.
However, offensive or foul odours such as rancid, putrid, or mouldy smells are signs that something has gone wrong with the starter.
If you encounter any of these unpleasant odours, it is advisable to discard the starter and begin the process of creating a new one. This is the best way to ensure the health and safety of your sourdough baking endeavors.
2. Mould Growth
Mould is another red flag!
While some starters might develop a thin layer of hooch (a liquid that forms on the surface), especially if they have been neglected, mould growth is a definite problem.
A mouldy sourdough starter will exhibit visible signs of mould growth, which can vary in appearance depending on the type of the mould.
Typically, visible mould appears as a fuzzy, powdery, or cotton-like growth on the top of your starter. The texture can range from fine and velvety to thicker and more substantial, depending on the type of mould.
It tends to form in irregular patches or spots. These patches can then spread and merge over time if the mould infestation is left unchecked.
The mould growth may also be accompanied by a musty or unpleasant odour, as described above.
It’s important to note that while mould growth on a sourdough starter is visible on the surface, the mould can also penetrate deeper into the starter. Therefore, even if you only see mould on the surface, it is likely that the entire starter is contaminated.
If you suspect your sourdough starter has developed mould, you should discard the starter as it could be harmful to eat. Then, thoroughly clean and sanitise any containers, utensils, or tools that came into contact with the mouldy starter to prevent cross-contamination.
You will then be ready to start the process of creating a new sourdough starter from scratch. Use clean equipment and follow proper sourdough starter hygiene practices to ensure a healthy and mould-free result.
To prevent mould growth in your sourdough starter in the future, be vigilant about maintaining proper hygiene and feeding schedules, keeping the starter in a clean container with a loose-fitting lid, and storing it in a cool, dry place.
Regularly refreshing the starter with fresh flour and water helps maintain a healthy balance of yeast and bacteria while discouraging mould growth.
3. Inactivity
A happy and thriving, active sourdough starter should rise and fall predictably after feedings. However, it can become less active or “weakened” if it hasn’t been properly maintained or regularly fed.
Signs that your sourdough starter may be “bad” or “weakened” due to inactivity include a lack of bubbling or no rise after feeding.
A healthy sourdough starter should produce bubbles and expand during the fermentation process. It should also rise and double in size within a reasonable time frame (usually 4-8 hours, depending on the ambient temperature). On the other hand, a weakened or inactive starter will not exhibit significant rise or growth.
Remember that sourdough starters are resilient and can often be revived with proper care and attention as you will see in the section below called ‘How to revive a struggling sourdough starter’. Once your starter is active and healthy again, you can use it to make delicious sourdough bread and other baked goods.
4. Strange Colouration
Sourdough starters can exhibit various colours, which can be influenced by factors such as the type of flour used, the age of the starter, and environmental conditions.
A typical sourdough starter, especially in the early stages of fermentation, is white or cream-coloured. It may become lighter in colour if it is mainly made with all-purpose or strong bread flour.
However, if the starter contains whole grains, a grey or brownish-grey tint could develop over time. This colouration is typically due to bran particles and is considered normal.
Likewise, a yellow or orange hue can occur in a starter that contains a significant amount of whole wheat or rye flour or a pink/red hue caused by wild yeast strains. These colours are not usually harmful and may add unique flavour profiles to the bread.
While some colours are normal and harmless, others may indicate issues with the starter’s health or possible contamination.
For example, a black, very dark brown, green or blue colour is unusual and may suggest mould growth or contamination with undesirable microorganisms. In such cases, it is advisable to exercise caution and discard the starter.
📷 Excessive Liquidity – Hooch
5. Excessive Liquidity
Excess liquid in a sourdough starter can be an indicator that the starter is not in a healthy or active state.
While some liquid separation in a sourdough starter is normal and can result in the formation of a layer known as “hooch”, an excessive amount of liquid can be a sign of various issues.
One common reason for excess liquid is that the starter has consumed all available food (flour and water) and is hungry. When the yeast and bacteria in the starter exhaust their food supply, they can produce excess liquid (hooch) as a byproduct. This is a sign that the starter needs to be fed more frequently.
Another reason is over-fermentation. In some cases, a starter may be left to ferment for too long without being refreshed (fed). This prolonged fermentation can lead to the production of excessive hooch and cause the starter to become overly acidic or develop off-flavours.
In rare cases, however, excess liquid might indicate contamination of the starter by unwanted microorganisms, such as bad bacteria or mould. These contaminants can disrupt the fermentation process and lead to liquid accumulation.
The good news is that by addressing excess liquid promptly and adjusting your feeding routine as needed, you can help ensure that your sourdough starter remains healthy for a long time.
6. An Odd Texture
The texture of a sourdough starter can provide important clues about its health and condition.
An odd or unusual texture may be an indication that the starter has gone bad or is experiencing issues.
Here’s how an odd texture of a sourdough starter could suggest it has gone bad:
- Slime or Slimy Texture – If your sourdough starter has developed a slimy or gooey texture, it is often a sign of overfermentation or the presence of unwanted microorganisms. This can make the starter unpleasant to work with and can affect the quality of your bread.
- Clumps or Lumps – Unusual clumps or lumps within the starter can suggest that it hasn’t been mixed or fed properly. These clumps can interfere with the fermentation process and result in uneven or unpredictable rising of the bread dough.
- Hard Crust or Surface – If a sourdough starter is left uncovered for extended periods without regular feedings, it may develop a hard crust or dried surface. While the inner part of the starter may still be viable, the crust that has formed on the surface of the starter should definitely be discarded as it can contain undesirable microorganisms.
- Rubbery or Tough Texture – An odd rubbery or tough texture can be a sign of overfermentation or excessive acidity in the starter. This can result in a starter that is less responsive to feedings and less capable of leavening bread properly.
- Fuzzy or Stringy Growth – If you notice fuzzy or stringy growth within the starter, it could indicate mould contamination. Mould can produce filaments that give the starter a stringy or web-like appearance. In such cases, the starter should be discarded.
Healthy sourdough starters should have a smooth, elastic texture. So, if you notice an unusual sliminess, grittiness, or any other textural changes, it is a cause for concern.
7. Persistent Problems
Lastly, if you’ve tried to revive your starter multiple times without success and it continues to exhibit signs of spoilage, it might simply be time to consider starting fresh with a new starter!
Factors That Can Affect Your Sourdough Starter
Understanding the signs of a potentially bad sourdough starter is essential, but it’s also crucial to be aware of the factors that can influence your starter’s health. This knowledge can help you prevent issues and maintain a thriving sourdough culture.
Temperature
Temperature plays a significant role in the activity of your sourdough starter. Cooler temperatures slow down fermentation, while warmer temperatures speed it up.
Extremely cold temperatures or extremely high temperatures can stress your starter and make it more susceptible to issues. In fact, if the temperature is too hot, the yeast will die off completely.
Feeding Schedule
Consistency in feeding is vital for maintaining a healthy sourdough starter.
Irregular feedings can lead to imbalances in the microbial community, affecting the overall health of your starter.
Water Quality
The quality of the water you use can impact your starter. This is because chlorinated or heavily treated tap water might hinder the beneficial microbial growth.
Using filtered or dechlorinated water is often recommended for this reason.
Flour Choice
Different flours contain varying levels of nutrients and microorganisms.
While all-purpose flour is commonly used, you can experiment with whole wheat, rye, or other flours to influence the flavour and characteristics of your starter.
Container Choice and Hygiene
The container you use to store your sourdough starter should be clean and free from residues. This is because neglecting container hygiene can introduce unwanted elements into your starter such as old food or bacteria. You should always use a clean jar.
In addition to this, the container should be made from a non-reactive material. This means that aluminium or copper containers are a no-no. In fact, it is best to stay away from any type of metal container altogether. Instead, choose a ceramic or glass container to store your sourdough starter.
It should have a cover or lid to stop debris entering the mix but not be airtight. Some people choose to cover a glass bowl with a tea towel to start with before investing in dedicated storage jars.
How to Revive a Struggling Sourdough Starter
If you have identified issues with your sourdough starter but believe it is salvageable, don’t despair. It is often possible to revive a struggling starter and bring it back to life, phew!
Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to do it:
1. Assess the Situation
The first thing to do is carefully examine your starter and identify the specific problems. Is it just a lack of activity, or are there signs of mould or spoilage?
Knowing what you’re dealing with will guide your actions.
2. Discard and Retain
Remove any crusty portions or excess liquid from your starter. Keep a small portion of the remaining starter, about 50g, to use as a foundation for revival.
3. Feed Your Starter
In a clean glass jar, combine the retained starter with equal parts flour and water (e.g. 50g starter, 50g flour, 50ml water). Mix until well combined, cover loosely, and let it sit at room temperature.
4. Repeat Feedings
Continue the feeding process at regular intervals, every 12 hours or so, until you see consistent signs of activity. This might take a couple of days or longer, depending on the severity of the issues.
5. Maintain a Consistent Feeding Schedule
Once your starter is back to its vigorous, bubbly self, maintain a regular feeding schedule to keep it healthy. A 1:1:1 ratio of starter, flour, and water is a common feeding ratio.
6. Consider Adjustments
If your starter continues to struggle, consider switching to a different flour or adjusting the hydration level to see if it responds better to those changes.
Preventing Future Issues with your Sourdough Starter
Prevention is often the best strategy to ensure your sourdough starter stays robust and doesn’t go bad in the first place.
Here are some tips to help you maintain a healthy starter:
Establish a Feeding Routine
Stick to a consistent feeding schedule, especially if you’re not baking frequently. Regular feedings keep your starter active and healthy.
Monitor Temperature
Be mindful of the ambient temperature in your kitchen. If it’s exceptionally hot or cold, adjust your feeding schedule accordingly.
Ideally it would be kept at around 21-24°C (70-75°F) to encourage yeast and bacterial activity.
For this reason, it is a good idea to use warm water when feeding for best results.
Use Quality Ingredients
Choose high-quality flour and clean, dechlorinated water to build and feed your starter.
Maintain Hygiene
Keep your container and utensils clean to prevent contamination of your starter. You may even consider buying a new jar for long term storage.
Experiment Thoughtfully
While experimentation can be fun, make changes to your starter gradually to avoid shocking its delicate balance.
Remember that your starter is a living organism and you should treat it as such.
Final thoughts on if a sourdough starter can go bad
A well-maintained sourdough starter is the heart and soul of excellent sourdough bread.
So, understanding the signs that your sourdough starter might be going bad and how to revive it when necessary is a valuable skill for any home baker.
Remember that sourdough baking is as much about patience and practice as it is about precision!
So, the next time you’re faced with a sourdough starter in distress, don’t panic. Assess the situation, follow the steps for revival, and with a little TLC, you’ll likely see your starter come back to life, ready to produce beautiful, tangy loaves of bread once more.
Happy baking!
If you enjoyed reading this, you may also like:
How to Make Easy Focaccia Flowers Bread Art
How Long Does a Sourdough Starter Last?
How Long can Sourdough Starter Stay in the Fridge?
How to Freeze Sourdough Starter and then Revive It
Is Sourdough Bread Dairy-Free?
