Ashwagandha vs Maca (2024)

Ashwagandha vs Maca

In the world of natural health, adaptogens have gained significant attention for their ability to support stress management, boost energy, restore and maintain hormonal balance, support the immune system, and aid cognitive function. These natural supplements, derived from traditional herbs, offer a comprehensive approach to overall wellbeing. In this blog we will compare the benefits of two of the most effective and popular adaptogens: Ashwagandha and Maca.

What are Adaptogens?

The term ‘adaptogen’ was first coined in 1940 by Russian scientist, N Lazarev. His definition of an adaptogen was a plant that can non-specifically enhance the human body. It was ruled that these substances must meet three criteria:

1. They must help the human body to resist a wide range of adverse conditions such as physical, chemical or biological stress.
2. They must maintain homeostasis in humans, this means they should offset or resist physical disorders caused by external stress.
3. Adaptogens must not cause harm to the normal function of the human body.

In the 1990s a group of scientists performed many studies on adaptogens and added further definition. They recorded that ‘adaptogens are natural bioregulators that increase the ability to adapt environmental factors and avoid the damage caused by those factors.’ source

Ashwagandha: An Ancient Ayurvedic Herbal Remedy

Ashwagandha has been used for centuries, and is much prized in Ayurveda, the ancient traditional medicine system originating from India. It has been recognised by scientists as a class 1 adaptogen due to its status as a plant used purely for its health-giving properties. This powerful adaptogen offers a wide range of health benefits that promote mind and body balance as well as overall vitality.

Stress Management and Relaxation

Ashwagandha has been found to correct the balance of cortisol, the main hormone responsible for stress levels. The active compounds in ashwagandha root, known as withanolides, help to calm the nervous system and promote greater mental peace, promote relaxation and ease the negative effects of stress, such as low mood, mental fatigue and insomnia.

Energy Boost and Stamina

Ashwagandha provides a natural energy boost which supports physical endurance and stamina. It is known to help combat fatigue and enhance vitality.

Hormonal Balance and Reproductive Health

This adaptogen has properties that promote hormonal balance, particularly for women. It can regulate menstrual cycles, reduce pre-menstrual stress, and support reproductive health.

Immune System Support and Vitality

Ashwagandha strengthens the immune system and increases the body’s resistance to stressors, helping to maintain good health and energy levels.

Cognitive Function and Mental Wellbeing

By reducing inflammation and oxidative stress, ashwagandha may improve cognitive function, memory, and mental wellbeing.

Improved Sleep Quality

Ashwagandha’s properties mimic the effect of gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), a brain activity neurotransmitter which helps regulate and soothe the nervous system. This helps with improved sleep quality.

Physical Performance and Endurance

Athletes often use ashwagandha to enhance physical performance. It helps boost endurance, stamina, and muscle strength.

Learn more about our Ashwagandha capsules.

Maca: The Peruvian Superfood

Maca, a traditional adaptogen from high in the Peruvian Andes, has gained popularity as both a superfood and a powerful herbal remedy in natural medicine. As a root vegetable, maca comes in three different colours, red, black and yellow (sometimes referred to as cream). They all have the same basic properties, but the skins of each colour contain additional beneficial compounds, making each one more suitable for various target uses. (See our blogs on each maca colour).

Energy Enhancement and Stamina Boost

Maca is known to increase energy levels, combat fatigue, and provide naturally enhanced stamina levels.

Hormonal Balance and Fertility Support

This adaptogen is recognised for its ability to support hormonal balance in both men and women. It has been used for centuries for its help with fertility issues.

Libido Boosting Properties

Maca is well known for boosting libido and improving sexual health.

Immune System Strengthening and Overall Vitality

Maca supports a healthy immune system, helping to prevent illness and encouraging general good health.

Cognitive Function and Mental Clarity

Maca has been linked to enhanced cognitive function and mental clarity. It can improve focus, memory, and concentration.

Athletic Performance and Physical Endurance

Maca is often used by athletes to improve their physical performance and endurance levels, making it a popular choice for those seeking to elevate their athletic abilities.

Learn more about our Maca capsules.

Comparison: Ashwagandha vs Maca

While both ashwagandha and maca belong to the group of herbal adaptogens and offer various health benefits for mind body balance, there are some key differences worth exploring:

Origins and Cultural Backgrounds – Ashwagandha is deeply rooted in traditional Indian medicine, Ayurveda, whereas maca’s origins are in the nutritional and natural medicine practices of Peru.

Specific Health Benefits and Targeted Effects – While ashwagandha is well known for its stress management and hormonal balance properties, maca is heralded for its energy enhancement and libido support.

Nutritional Profiles and Active Ingredients – Ashwagandha is rich in alkaloids, steroidal lactones and withanolides, whereas maca contains essential amino acids, vitamins, and minerals.

Ashwagandha vs Maca: Which Adaptogen to Choose?

When deciding between ashwagandha and maca, several factors should be considered:

• Personal Health Goals and Needs – Assess your individual health needs and preferences. If you are looking for stress management and hormonal balance, ashwagandha may prove to be your optimal choice. Alternatively, if you seek an energy boost and libido support, maca could be the ideal adaptogen for you.
• Allergies or Sensitivities – Consider any allergies or sensitivities you may have to specific ingredients present in the adaptogens. Be sure to establish that any medication you are currently taking, or health issues you have, are not included on the list of warnings associated with your choice.

Both ashwagandha and maca are powerful adaptogens that offer numerous health benefits. Their traditional backgrounds, distinct properties, and targeted effects make them valuable herbal remedies in the pursuit of holistic health and wellness.

It is always recommended that you consult a healthcare professional or qualified herbalist to receive advice tailored to your specific needs.

Is it Okay to Take Ashwagandha and Maca together?

There is no reason why you shouldn’t take ashwagandha and maca at the same time. Both supplements have no known negative interactions when taken together.

If you decide to take both together you get benefits from ashwagandha’s stress-fighting properties and maca’s energy-boosting powers.

Ten Key Takeaways

• Adaptogens are powerful natural supplements that promote stress management and overall wellbeing.
• Ashwagandha is an ancient Ayurvedic remedy known for stress reduction, energy boost, and hormonal balance.
• Maca is a Peruvian superfood that enhances energy, hormonal balance, cognitive function, and boosts libido.
• Both ashwagandha and maca offer immune support and physical performance benefits.
• Ashwagandha’s active ingredients include withanolides.
• Maca’s active ingredients include vitamins and minerals.
• Choose ashwagandha for stress management and improved sleep.
• Choose maca for energy, hormonal balance and libido support.
• Consider personal health goals, allergies, and health issues when choosing an adaptogen.
• Taking ashwagandha and maca together is safe and may well be advantageous in meeting your individual needs.

Further Reading

You may be interested in more detailed information about ashwagandha and maca in our recent blogs:

• Ashwagandha for Sleep
• Ashwagandha for Menopause
• Ashwagandha Benefits for Men
• Ashwagandha Benefits for Women
• Yellow Maca Benefits
• Black Maca Benefits
• Red Maca Benefits
• Maca Benefits for Women

Our Promise

When it comes to keeping you informed on health and nutrition, we’re here for you and aim to help where we can. If you would like to discuss any aspect of using natural supplements, or would find advice helpful, please feel free to contact us on 01297 553932

Associated Supplement Products

Ashwagandha Root Extract

Maca Root Extract