Looking for the best cookies in NYC? Well, you’re in the right place!
Cookies and milk aren’t just for kids, all the best cookie shops in NYC can prove you that! If you’re a big fan of this treat, ranging from savory to sweet flavors, even the strangest flavors you might ever find, you’re going to find them all here in this guidance!
So, are you ready to hop on this cookie journey with us?
Hold on tight, as we are going to give you the lowdown on some of the best cookie shops in NYC.
This article contains affiliate links where we may get a small commission if you click on the link and purchase. No extra cost is added to you.
Find Cheap Flights To New York:
1. Levain Bakery
Levain Bakery is an iconic spot in New York, and is famous for its colossal, gooey cookies that weigh in at a staggering six ounces each!
Visiting Levain Bakery, you’ll find this place filled with both locals and tourists, lining up to try their baked-to-perfection cookies! Pay a visit to Levain Bakery and try them yourself!
Here, they bake fresh and ship same-day, so cookies arrive deliciously crispy and soft for immediate enjoyment.
Best-sellers are Caramel Coconut Chocolate Chip, which is coconutty, buttery, caramel-y, and tastes nothing like what you’ve tried before!
Don’t just stop there, go on with the Dark Chocolate Chip – the ultimate chocolate cookie – which is dense, chewy, and dangerously rich.
This goodness is sure to satisfy even the biggest chocoholic.
Or the rich and buttery Oatmeal Raisin cookies that are golden brown on the outside, moist on the inside, and full of plump sweet raisins! Yummy!
What to Order: Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie, Caramel Coconut Chocolate Chip, Dark Chocolate Chip Cookie, Oatmeal Raisin
Address:
– 167 W 74th St, New York, NY 10023
– 1484 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10028
– 351 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
– 340 Lafayette St, New York, NY 10012
– 2167 Frederick Douglass Blvd, New York, NY 10026
Website | Instagram | Facebook
2. Schmackary’s
Located in Hell’s Kitchen, Schmackary’s is a cookie haven offering a wide array of unique and classic flavors.
If you’re in search of unique and new creations, this place is a must-visit! Come by and let your palate be impressed!
The Maple Bacon cookie is a standout, combining the sweetness of maple syrup with the savory crunch of bacon.
Other popular flavors include Cookie & Cream, which can cause instant crush with Oreo cookie crumbs, white chocolate, and vanilla frosting; and Sweet Corn – inspired by Southern cornbread – is stuffed with toasted pecans and cranberries.
These badasses can please even the most discerning taste buds!
Have a liking for cheese? Schmuck & Cheese is made just for you!
They put macaroni inside a cookie along with crispy bacon and their own 4 cheese blend. It’s a little sweet, mostly savory, and 100% delicious!
Need to freshen things up? Grab the fresh and light Key Lime!
What to Order: Maple Bacon Cookie, Cookie & Cream Cookie, Sweet Corn Cookie, Schamack & Cheese Cookie, Key Lime Cookie
Address: 362 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036
Website | Instagram | Facebook
🗽 Foodie? Check out these NYC-guided food tours!
3. Cindy Lou’s Cookies
Cindy Lou’s Cookies is a New York-based bakery that specializes in big, old-fashioned, seriously delicious cookies that are intended to warm the heart and nourish the soul.
Here, you’ll find all sorts of flavors, ranging from classics like Chocolate Chip and Oatmeal Raisin to unique offerings like Lemon Lavender and S’mores!
This lovely place has something for every palate, and they also offer vegan and gluten-free options, which are inclusive for all cookie lovers!
Start with some Nutella Swirl, a delicious chocolate chip cookie base with heath bar candy added for crunch, and swirled with Nutella for a perfect twist on the classic.
Wanna upgrade it a bit?
Grab the Coconut Macaroon with a soft, coconut-vanilla taste, even if you don’t like coconut, you’ll love this badass from Cindy Lou’s!
Lemon Cloud is another crowd’s favorite, made with fresh lemon juice and lemon zest while white chocolate chips are added to create the ultimate flavor combination of sweet and tart!
For something even crazier, 7-Layer with pretzels, potato chips, butterscotch chips, chocolate chips, oats, graham crackers, and marshmallows blended together will blow your mind!
What to Order: Nutella Swirl, Coconut Macaroon, Lemon Cloud, Peanut Butter & Jelly, 7-Layer
Address: 398 10th Ave, New York, NY 10001
Website | Instagram | Facebook
4. Crumbl Cookies
Crumbl Cookies is a rapidly expanding cookie chain that has found its way to New York City’s Upper West Side.
Known for their massive, gourmet cookies, Crumbl offers a rotating weekly menu featuring six specialty flavors.
Come by and experience all of their stunning cookies!
Currently, the French Silk Pie is the best-seller, a chilled dark chocolate pie-inspired cookie layered with velvety chocolate mousse, a dollop of whipped cream, and a delicate sprinkle of chocolate curls.
It feels so smooth and rich in the mouth, and each bite tastes like heaven!
The Snickerdoodle Cupcake is no less stunning, a warm cinnamon sugar cookie topped with cream cheese frosting and an extra dash of cinnamon sugar.
What to Order: French Silk Pie, Snickerdoodle Cupcake, Chocolate Peanut Butter Puffs, Cookie Butter Lava
Address:
– 1195 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10021
– 301 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023
– 238 7th Ave, New York, NY 10011
– 195 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10012
– 20 Soundview Market Pl Unit #7, Port Washington, NY 11050
Website | Instagram | Facebook
5. Janie’s Life-Changing Baked Goods
Janie’s Life-Changing Baked Goods is not just a bakery; it’s a social enterprise with a mission.
Founded by Janie Deegan, who overcame addiction and homelessness, the bakery aims to provide second chances through mentorship and employment.
Pay a visit to experience their stunning cookies and support the business as well!
Their Half Baked Chocolate Chip Cookie is a crowd favorite, offering a gooey center with a slightly crispy edge.
It’s caramelized on the outside, and chewy on the inside, with milk chocolate discs, milk, and semisweet chocolate chips.
Another popular item is the Pie Crust Cookie, in which each bite gives you a flaky crust, a thin layer of filling, and the most buttery, caramelized streusel.
Don’t leave without having a bite of their S’mores Cookie, loaded with milk chocolate discs, semi-sweet chocolate chips, mini marshmallows, graham cracker pieces, and topped off with more marshmallows, graham cracker pieces, and Hershey’s milk chocolate! Tasty!
What to Order: Half Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies, Pie Crust Cookie, S’mores Cookies
Address:
– 212 W 80th St, New York, NY 10024
– 2118 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10029
– 82 Christopher St, New York, NY 10014
Website | Instagram | Facebook
6. Gooey on The Inside Cookies
Gooey on The Inside stays true to its name when specializing in gooey-center cookies while the edges are perfectly crispy, ranging in many flavors!
The cookies are baked to order and shipped nationwide, making it possible for cookie aficionados outside of New York City to indulge in these delicious treats.
They also offer vegan and gluten-free options, ensuring that everyone can enjoy their cookies!
The most popular choice is definitely the Birthday Cake Cookie, which comes with white chocolate chunks, real birthday cake flavor, colorful sprinkles, and an ooey gooey center.
We assure you you will enjoy the very last bite!
Or you can go for their Dark Chocolate Caramel S’mores with a sumptuous blend of French milk chocolate, dark chocolate, marshmallows, and dark chocolate cookies to make this childhood treat come to life.
For a fresh treat, their Custard Berry Tart filled with blackberry jam and topped with seasonal berries will not disappoint you!
What to Order: Birthday Cake Cookie, Dark Chocolate Caramel S’mores, Custard Berry Tart, Key Lime Pie
Address: 163 Chrystie St, New York, NY 10002
Website | Instagram | Facebook
🗽 New to NYC? Try these guided city tours to get the best of the Big Apple!
7. Chip City
Chip City is a cookie lover’s paradise located in New York City. Founded in 2017, the bakery has quickly gained a reputation for its mouthwatering, oversized cookies.
With a rotating menu of over 50 flavors, Chip City offers a unique experience every time you visit.
With multiple locations across the city, Chip City is a must-visit for anyone looking to satisfy their cookie cravings!
Their Chocolate Peanut Butter is a must, which is creamy, and salty yet so smooth. Don’t miss the taste if you love the combination of peanut butter and chocolate.
The Nutella Sea Salt Cookie is another crowd’s favorite, made with brown sugar cookies mixed with toasted hazelnuts and filled with Nutella. Stunning!
Something more unique?
Try the Horchata with hints of rice milk, and coconut oil, which is filled with horchata, and rolled in cinnamon sugar. Sweet and aromatic as ever!
We personally love the Lemon Berry and Blueberry Cheesecake Cookies as they have a certain freshness, tartness, and juiciness in each bite!
What to Order: Nutella Sea Salt Cookie, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Horchata, Lemon Berry, Blueberry Cheesecake
Address:Multiple locations
Website | Instagram | Facebook
8. Red Gate Bakery
Red Gate Bakery is a charming East Village bakery that brings a modern twist to classic American baked goods.
Here, you’re not only gonna find high-quality cookies but stunning cakes, and bars also!
With its cozy atmosphere and innovative menu, Red Gate Bakery is a hidden gem that cookie enthusiasts should not miss.
One of their standout cookie options is the “O.G. with Sea Salt,” a classic chocolate chip cookie elevated with a sprinkle of sea salt.
Cardamodoodle is a warm and bright sugar cookie coated in cardamom sugar, which is crinkly and soft just like what you’d expect.
While the Confetti Cookie is a plush and rich one with colorful rainbow sprinkles on top!
How about trying an everything-kind-of cookie? Their Kitchen Sinkeer loaded with oats, coconut, chocolate, and potato chips is going to surprise your palate!
There’s something for everyone in there, so what’s stopping you from grabbing one?
What to Order: Cardamodoodle, Confetti Cookies, Choco-Toffee Cookie, Kitchen Sinker Cookies, O.G. with Sea Salt
Address: 68 E 1st St, New York, NY 10003
Website | Instagram | Facebook
9. City Cakes
Located in Chelsea, City Cakes is known for its half-pound cookies that are as big as they are delicious!
The bakery offers a variety of flavors, from the classic Chocolate Chip to the exotic Macadamia White Chocolate. Each cookie is perfectly crisp on the outside while remaining gooey on the inside, while the setting is cozy, and the service is friendly.
If you have a big love for cookies, this place surely won’t let you down!
They have a wide range of unique, creative cookies, so it’s easy to understand that you want to try a bit of everything!
The Tarty Party Lemon is the most outstanding one, with a lemon sugar cookie base filled with citrus curd, and then rolled in Fruity Pebbles Cereal before it is baked to perfection. Chewy, tart, sweet, and slightly crunchy.
“Dark Horse” Salted Double Chocolate Chip is the newest item on the menu, made with dark onyx cocoa cookie dough base, Callebaut semi-sweet chocolate chips, and flakes of black sea salt on top.
This is totally a different kind of chocolate bliss!
In case you want to play safe, grab the Signature Sugardoodle, which is just a bit different from a Snickerdoodle because it’s just lightly dusted with cinnamon.
What to Order: Tarty Party Lemon, “Dark Horse” Salted Double Chocolate Chip, Killer Stuffed Red Velvet, Signature Sugardoodle
Address: 155 W 18th St, New York, NY 10011
Website | Instagram | Facebook
Well there you have it!
There are still a ton of delicious food spots to hit up while you’re in the Big Apple. Whether that be Italian food or Sushi or just the best restaurants in Brooklyn!
How We Create Our “Best” Lists
All Noms Magazine’s “best” lists are created using multiple factors and signals to help readers find the best restaurants, things to do, and places to stay at. Some of these factors and signs include personal experiences, correspondence with locals, and compiling experiences from review sites.
Each list is also created to be balanced (in terms of price, cuisine type, ambiance, and more) as possible. This means that the lists are not specifically created in ranking order. You should be comfortable picking from any of the spots on the list and generally have a good time. But of course, YMMV (your mileage may vary) and everyone may have different experiences/palates.
